Why Random Job Search Networking Doesn’t Work Today
Dec 12 2012 in Featured, Networking/Social Networking, reCareered Blog by Phil Rosenberg
… or Why You Need To Change How You Network
Most of you are used to job search networking. It’s no big deal to send your resume to your entire contact list or to attend networking events to shake hands and ask about job openings.
Are you using random networking?
You’re using random networking if you:
- Send/email your resume to your contact list, alumni list, or any other list
- Use a resume mailing/emailing service to reach employers
- Bring your resume or ask for help randomly at networking events
Most of you are convinced that if you send your resumes to enough contacts and meet enough people at networking events, you’ll get enough interviews to get a good job. After all, it’s probably how you got many interviews (and possibly job offers) during your last job search.
But most of you are surprised (at first) and then frustrated that these random networking tactics aren’t generating many interviews in today’s job market.
… because the job market has changed. It’s changed enough to make these old, “tried and true” tactics no longer effective.
These three steps were at the core of most career advisers’ strategies. Unfortunately, many career advisers still teach the same tactics … ignoring the massive changes in today’s job market and how those changes have affected employer hiring processes and decisions.
Why random networking doesn’t work today:
- Job shortages, not candidate shortages: Random networking worked when there was so much low hanging fruit that all you had to do was talk to random people in your network and you’d have enough interviews to get a decent job. One problem … we haven’t had a job market of candidate shortages for nearly 6 years.
- Effects of The Patriot Act: The Patriot Act changed hiring processes for public, private, large small, profit, non-profit, education, health care and government employers. It required that employers keep copies of passports, Social Security cards, or green cards to prove new hires have the right to work in the US. More importantly, it empowered the DOL to conduct surprise random labor audits, checking compliance with all federal hiring laws … including fair hiring laws under the EEOC. Companies that flunked could be take over and shut down by the US Government.
- Guaranteed interview loophole closed: Guaranteed interview policies existed at most companies as written or verbal policies. But due to market changes eliminating candidate shortages and legal changes due to The Patriot Act, companies began to quickly eliminate these policies to avoid risk of failing a DOL audit.
- Replaced with Employee Referral Bonus programs: Guaranteed interviews were replaced by Employee Referral Bonus programs, essentially a bribe to encourage employees to send resumes received from friends, family and network into HR. If the referred candidate is hired, the employee gets a sizable bonus, typically thousands of dollars, just for sending the candidate’s resume into HR. This helped companies reduce risk of failing labor audits, by setting up a process to shut down attempted bypass of the HR department and Applicant Tracking System.
- Mass competition: Mass job competition weakened random networking effectiveness even more. When you compete against an average 1,000 candidates and random networking is just an express train to the Applicant Tracking System, random networking becomes futile.
When you use traditional random networking techniques, you’re using the wrong tool for the wrong problem.
Instead, use a focused networking strategy, targeting specific individuals at specific companies on your target list. Think of networking primarily as a way to gain information about the company and less about networking as a way to ask for a job.
By targeting your networking, you’re less likely to waste your time and more likely to reach the right people.
… Because random job search networking is a thing of the past.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Want to do more than just complain about a bad economy?
To attend our next complimentary live webinar featuring action items to double your resume response rate and number of interviews, plus live career Q&A with Phil Rosenberg of reCareered, register at http://ResumeWebinar.com .
Join our mailing list to for newsletters, announcements of complimentary upcoming webinars and other job search resources. Sign up at http://www.reCareered.com/newsletter/
For access to more information:
Connect to Phil Rosenberg on Linkedin: http://linkedin.com/in/philrosenberg
Follow reCareered on Linkedin: http://linkedin.com/company/recareered.com
"Like" reCareered on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/reCareered
Follow Phil Rosenberg on Google+: http://gplus.to/philrosenberg
Follow reCareered on Twitter: http://twitter.com/philreCareered
Join Career Change Central on Linkedin: http://linkedin.com/e/gis/1800872
Source: http://reCareered.com
Author: Phil Rosenberg
You might also like
| 7 Alumni Networking Don’ts I'm proud to have been named a bi-weekly columnist of TheLadders. I will be republishing my articles... | Make Your Network Links Strong Like Bull If you use a tight networking strategy in LinkedIN or Facebook, you want strong links. But even in a... | Start Developing Good Networking Karma! Kirsten Gauthier-Newbury of Marylhurst University Career Services Blog quoted an earlier article in her... | Make Your Network Links Strong Like Bull If you use a tight networking strategy in Linkedin or Facebook, you want strong links. But even in... |











Even though job search networking is one of the most successful ways to find a new job, it can sound intimidating and sometimes seems a little bit scary. It doesn’t have to be. My father ended up in a conversation on an airplane with someone who was looking for an aeronautical engineering job. My dad happened to be in the same field and ended up assisting the person in getting a new job. Sometimes, that’s all it takes. I’ve been offered jobs on more than one occasion simply because a friend or acquaintance knew my background and skills.
@lannister – Sure you have … I have also. But that was then, this is now. You’ll see in the article that random networking used to be extremely effective because of guaranteed interview policies, candidate shortages, a less competitive job market, and before federal laws that made it more difficult to get interviews based on who you know.
I’m not saying random networking never works today. But it’s not anywhere near as effective as it was pre-2007. Today’s effective job search networking is highly focused. Since most job seekers only know how to network randomly, it’s a low-odds chance of working well in your job search.